I recently read an interview with Joan Mitchell in the outstanding new book, Joan Mitchell: Paintings 1979-1985 (David Zwirner Books, 2024). In her conversation with the French Philosopher Yves Michaud, Mitchell makes the assertion that painting is the only art form that is without time.
“[Painting] never ends,” she says. “It is both continuous and still.”
Her statement has confounded and intrigued me since I read it. Mitchell wants us to consider time as contained in and emitted by art works, rather than time as mere context or content. The concept feels familiar in my experience of both making and looking at art—that is that, in the best scenario, a painted image stays with us in an indelible way, out past the capabilities of language, beyond the boundaries of time. It can be of the moment that it is made and of the moment it is viewed, and it can transcend both.
However, I have also wondered, what if painting is not the only art form that is without time? Can the same be said of poetry? After all— language, in both the way it is intended and the way it is read, can also be both “continuous and still.”
And so, here is my poem, “Letters to Our Daughters,” to read while you chew on Mitchell’s concept of time in art. I began writing this poem in June 2023, several months after I started down a treacherous road of cancer treatment. The poem has evolved since then as I have returned to it, trimming and word-shifting every so often. It changed with the ebbs and flows of the last 15 months; through my last chemotherapy treatment exactly one year ago today; through the surgery that came after it; through my recovery and months of further infusions. And it changed with the other manifold, dynamic and vital aspects of my life outside of the the realm of cancer: my treasured relationships, my art, my self.
And to me that feels just right. Maybe this has become a poem that spans time; it is of the time it was made, and of the present moment, where it will remain for you to read now, even as now continues to move in to the future as it always tends to do.
Now.
And now.
And now.
LETTERS TO OUR DAUGHTERS by Lindsay Gardner People are made of the same thing as stars, she wrote with a bright yellow number two pencil a giant revelation on a tiny scrap words that play like lyrics in my head when I wake, sweating where we lay, unmoored, even the moon has vanished Noiselessly I chase the stories of their boundless souls– a desperate quest for adequate language until daylight clear and callous devours me No– I can name more precisely in the weightless, lightless murk of two to four am hair skin nails baby teeth hip bone big toe knee cap ear lobe thumb wrist eyes palm nostril hand on my hand the exact unnamable hue of their eyes (your eyes, my eyes) freckle below wispy lash (we named it) the smell of baking bread while she slept (we named it) her silken flesh against this wicked breast (unnamable) ache too tender for this world (unspeakable) Again and again in the dark I burn just to be here to meet the sun when it rises again over the gray hill to make myself a mirror for them to blow their breath on; to feel them fog it up with their hot aliveness to write all the letters I did not write for them across the years to yield to this thirst to trace the everything of their existence to make apparent infinity to map our impossible galaxies– the absurd thickets– of all we cannot, will not know to listen to them to ask their millions of unasked questions as they keep answering mine
Thank you.
gorgeous, beautifully paced poem